“The Grace Year” Book-Club Review

So, ever since last year my local book-club started a new method of book selection - since we are all very much thriller-lovers and kept picking, well, thrillers.

It boils down to picking a new literary genre at random, and then, after submitting titles, one is selected by lottery. It’s been working really well so far, too: we’ve ended up with some great new picks.

But this month’s pick left me feeling a little nervous because of the genre that was selected: Dystopian.

I’m normally a pretty up-beat person to begin with, and was deeply unsettled from early dystopian-reads mandated by high school law: Lord of Flies, 1984, A Brave New World, are the ones that really put the screws to my timid, 14-year-old brain.

But now that I’m almost 20 years older - and hopefully just a little bit wiser - these titles no longer frighten me as much as they used to. In fact, I’ve actually grown to appreciate them as scholarly and artistic works in their own right.

So even though Dystopian is not really my genre, I felt confident I’d be able to engage with this month’s pick in a way that was sincerely meaningful and -

Well… shoot!…


I’ve never been into the Y.A. scene… even when I myself was a beat-bopping-young-adult. It’s just never really interested me, especially once I got older and really started to tire of the “chosen one” shtick.

But this was an engaging read at times, so I’m pleased this was my brief return to Y.A. Engaging as it was, though, I didn’t particularly like it. It’s not at all a bad read, of course. I just didn’t gel with it that’s all.

The Synopsis

To say that this debut novel is the love-child of Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale and Suzanne Collin’s The Hunger Games (with just a hint Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” for that extra hint of drama) is a very apt description.

16-year-old Tierney James, is about to embark on the ever dreaded “Grace Year.” The year in which she and all the other 16-year-old girls of their community must survive the wilderness - and each other - in order to expel their “dangerous magic” and become “proper women” (I’ll let you imagine the unapologetic eye-rolls in that statement).

Despite having a slight leg-up on the other girls, by way of a survival education, Tierney soon finds herself outnumbered and outmatched against the potential enemies who now surround her… but also by the absolute depths of their beliefs instilled in them since birth.

 

The premise alone is worth checking out, I promise.

If you ever wanted to know what Lord of the Flies would like through the perspective of young ladies, then look no further: this book will answer all the gory questions you have!

But, like I said, I just didn’t vibe much with it once I hit play on my Audible app. To explain why, we’re gonna have to get into the nitty-gritty of the story so strap in… it’s going to be one hell of a ride!

Minor Spoilers ahead! You have been warned!!

 

Now, out of respect for the artist behind the story, I like to start this DNF Critique by exploring what I did like about the book.

 
  1. An Intriguing Premise:

I’m not lying when I say that this story helps answer the long-held questions I’ve had regarding my old high-school-foe, “The Lord of the Flies”:

Would this survival story look any different if it were a bunch of school-aged girls?

To my surprise (and mild horror) the answer is a resounding “NO.”

And “YES”…

Let me explain:

As with our old high school delight, Liggett very perceptively pin-points the inherit power-dynamics that come with restrictive communities. Tierney’s nemesis, Kirsten, is very much a young lady dedicated to their old ways, as she directly and amply benefits from those old ways.

Even though it’s clear that Tierney is the most qualified to help them all survive the wilderness, Kirsten slowly gains power, one girl at a time, from sheer charisma (combined with spiked well-water). And there is a reason why: Tierney has always seen herself as separate from her female classmates.

And they’ve always known it. And likely resent Tierney for it, especially since she’s a girl with such a high favor from her father.

As with “The Lord of the Flies,” two camps are inevitably formed even among children- because children often mirror what their parents model for them. And the way Kirsten wins the other girls over is very much in the same way as Jack from LOTF: a whole lot of natural charm, confidence, strategic manipulation, and scapegoating.

Unlike the boys, however, the girls take their wild-and-uninhibited-descent-into-insanity with so much more blood-lust…

2. A Well-Written Yarn:

The fact that Liggett clearly pulls from such giants of Western Literature is proof of just how much thought she gave to this story while writing. She skillfully pulls the reader into the pulse-pounding action of the narrative and never lets up for a moment.

One minute you’re exploring the world of Garner County, learning it’s culture and immersed in its atmosphere - and then the next minute you’re racing through the wilderness, chased by half-crazed teenagers and praying to God they don’t catch you because they will pull you apart limb from limb…

To say it gave me flashbacks to high school is a bit of an understatement.

I cannot stress enough just how much of a good writer Kim Liggett is with this novel. She balances Teirnery’s inner-voice really well with strong scenes and dynamic action. Even though I couldn’t bring myself to finish the book, I was certainly never bored with it.

Of course, that kind of leads me to the things I didn’t like about the book…

 
  1. A surprising Lack of Lore:

We know who is the primary character of this book: Teirnery James.

We know why these things are happening in this book: misogynistic pricks.

We even know where the most of the book takes place: Garner county.

However, what we don’t know really know is when the book is taking place. Or even if it’s within our own established reality or history. For all we know, this entire plot could be taking place on a completely different planet.

This is definitely unusual in our modern interpretation of dystopian literature, which often takes place in either a distant but eerily-similar, future, or in a completely alternate reality in which the butterfly-effect reigns supreme (Hello, The Man in the High Castle!).

While it’s not necessarily a bod choice to omit a specific timeline from a piece of speculative fiction, I do think it leaves the story with a pretty big handicap - as without a timeline there’s no frame of reference to help ground my suspension of disbelief. I know that sounds like a complete oxymoron, but hear me out:

As a woman who’s already experienced girlhood in full (and then some), there’s nothing about this novel’s themes that I haven’t already heard backwards and forwards (and multiple times). Especially today, everyone’s got their own opinions about womanhood and it’s relationship to femininity. There’s many people today who want to see us “go back” to “the good old days,” where women were essentially treated like something between slave and cattle.

Something my own father vehemently warned me about.

And while I’m always game for feminist discord and how society shapes relationships between women - I literally have no idea how things can possibly get thatbad in Teirney’s world!

By the time I decided to turn off the audio-book, I was coming dangerously close to treating the rest of the book like a drinking-game: take a shot every time someone said the word “magic,” despite knowing that I’d be 3-sheets to the wind in less 10 minutes.

The only reason I held in for as a long as I did with The Grace Year is because of Liggett’s story-telling; the further and further I got into the book, the more I kept holding out hope that Liggett would eventually explain the framework of this world and how things got this bad for them -

At one point I even broke out the cork-board and red-string, believing that she was creating a feminist-interpretation of the M. Night Shamalyan’s ‘The Village,’ only not terribly executed…

But, alas, as the Garner-Girls careened further and further into bloody and unhinged insanity, I finally had to take a break long enough to google the spoilers… and was a little disappointed.

No explanation for how Garner County was formed;

no larger conspiracy to explain why their men are as dumb as a sack of bricks;

Nothing.

Once I realized there was no ghost to unmask, no cults to bust up, no threads to connect, I completely lost interest in the story.

Not that Tierney James ever really had my attention to begin with…

2. A Lack-luster Lead

One thing I did like about Katniss Everdeen from The Hunger Games series, is that she felt like a whole-person. Though she was only 16 herself in the first novel, she clearly lived a life in a world that made sense to her - and one that she actively challenged, even in very small ways. Her growing from a survivor to an active rebel made sense because she was on her own hero’s journey.

Tierney James, meanwhile, is not nearly as interesting a character.

We see her waiver between logic and dogma as early as the girl’s first hour into the journey to their encampment - an hour, guys! They haven’t even been drugged by nasty well-water yet!

Even though Tierney is supposed to have an edge over the others by way of her father’s survival training, it never feels like she’s actually been educated or trained… or even has common sense at times. I know most people have never had to fetch drinking water from well, but common sense dictates that if people are suddenly acting crazy, with pupils the size of dinner-dishes, then they’re probably drinking poisoned-water.

Teirney puzzles this out as soon as they get to their encampment, but the minute she receives any push back (especially from Kirsten) she crumbles like a house of cards, simply because she can’t explain why the well-water’s bad. Meanwhile, logic dictates that, when it comes to poisoned-water the why or how doesn’t matter in the end… it’s f*cking poisoned. Are you stupid? Don’t drink it!!

It was incredibly hard for me to connect with Teirney because she didn’t feel like a fully-fleshed out person.

I get the sense that, when it came to writing this lead, Liggett was trying to have her cake and eat it, too: she was trying to create a Katniss Everdeen-type without committing to the warrior-archetype that Katniss embodies. And how could she? Teirney is raised in a community where girls spend their lives in a cage and are literally bred for more breeding. And, consequently, never taught how to fight or advocate for themselves.

This actually helps explain why Kirsten so easily won over the other girls at the camp: Kirsten, as vile as she is, has charisma - and Teirney has none at all.

This could’ve been an interesting set up for a slow-burn “battle of wills” between Teirney and Kirsten, with the bulk of the action taking place only at the camp. Shoot! Throw in some romantic intrigue if you want.

Out of all the girls who have been through the Grace Year, your telling me not a single one of them was gay?*

Sexuality and how that informs female relationships is not nearly explored enough in our current media landscape, and this would fit perfectly in a closed-circle story.

But in order for any of that to happen, Teirnery would first have to be an interesting character.

As she is now, she doesn’t even feel like she’s Katniss-adjacent, despite Liggett’s writing talents.

Frankly, I think I would’ve appreciated Teirnery more if the story itself wasn’t so… bloody.

3. Too Much Viscera

Contrary to what some may think, I’m actually not a squeamish person. I have cleaned up everything from blood to literal sh*t, from a variety of colorful sources, so when it comes to gore there’s nothing you can throw at me that I can’t handle…

Though, that doesn’t mean that I necessarily want to have it thrown at me…

Using blood and gore does have it’s place in some stories, but because it’s so disconcerting it needs to be handled carefully, and with intention. That lack of care and intention is typically what causes violence to cross the line from provocative into cruelty - and Liggett tap-dances dangerously close to that line many times in her novel. Even as early as the first couple of chapters.

Before anyone can say the boneheaded thing they want to say: no, it’s not because this is female-driven story. I grew up in the public schools of central-Kentucky… where the preps and the hillbillies can all come together and collective hate each other when they’re not ganging up on someone else.

I know girls can be especially violent.

As much as I like what Kim Liggett is going for in this book, I just can’t bring myself to read anymore about little girls literally being ripped to shreds… for the sake of an aphrodisiac.

(I let you image the gag-reflex I just felt right there)

To be completely blunt about it: this novel is just too brutal for my taste.

 

In Conclusion:

The Grace Year it bloody, provocative, entertaining…. and comes this close to being a page-turner.

Even though I was never bored as I was reading, I also just couldn’t bring myself to finish it once I realized certainly elements were not going to change. Teirney was too uninteresting for me to really care about her; there wasn’t enough lore for me to chew on; and the gore was just too much for me to stomach on first read.

I didn’t even mention the love-story that was inserted halfway through!

My book-club told me it, and apparently I didn’t miss too much: they thought it kind of came completely out of the blue… and then when it ended it just kind of ended? They way they described it there was no real weight behind this relationship, which made it kind of a let-down.

Kim Liggett is a very talented writer, with a strong and distinct voice. I just think maybe she was getting too wrapped into some of those long-standing YA troupes, when she would’ve been better off exploring and experimenting with her own ideas. She’s got a lot of great ideas. So great, in fact, that she shouldn’t try to force them into a specific mold.

One day maybe I’ll finish this book. As long as I take lots of little breaks in-between. But to be honest, I’d rather just track down some of her more recent work instead. I cannot wait to see where else Kim Ligget goes from here!


*at our meeting last month I found out that Kirsten is actually gay, and that’s why she threw her former-friend/lover under the bus in Garner County!

Previous
Previous

“Little Inconveniences”

Next
Next

End of an Era