Shallow Feminism
The Most Confusing “Feminist” Film I’ve ever Seen
Alex Garland is a director best known for his creative, mesmerizing approach to filming esoteric stories. He is very good at making these really creative pulls from some of the most obscure ideas and translating the nuance into a thought-provoking way for general audiences…
And I want my 1 hour and 41 minutes back after viewing 2022’s MEN.
The story is deceptively simple in its premise:
Harper Marlowe (Jessie Buckley) retreats to the picturesque country-side following the death of her husband, James (Paapa Essiedu). However, her healing journey takes a nasty turn as more and more disturbing events seem to converge around her in this strange village - seemingly only populated by men (Rory Kinnear, in multiple roles).
A simple premise, with many great ideas connected to it because of its simplicity… and Garland manages to waff the whole thing.
Though beautifully shot and accompanied with superb sound-design - staples of Garland’s directorial style - the sheer beauty of this movie and the talent of the cast are not enough to save this befuddling mess of a “feminist” folk-horror film…
I’d even argue it’s a mess of a folk-horror film to be perfectly blunt:
Who is the “Green Man?”
No seriously - who is this guy supposed to be? The only thing I know about him is that he’s a pagan figure and that he’s called “the Green Man.” That’s it - that’s literally all I know as of now (further research is necessary). I’m assuming that there’s also a connection to nature and fertility, based on what I saw in the movie, but again inference is not the same as knowing… and there is surprisingly little to use for inference in this movie.
My point is this: whatever was meant to be the “folk-horror” of this movie is completely lost on me personally, because I don’t know what is supposed to make these pagan elements fearful in this context. And for all of the beautiful nature-shots and surreal-imagery, this movie still doesn’t give me enough context to fill in those gaps as someone who doesn’t come from a pagan-background.
An over-bloated 101 minute run-time
At a little over an hour and half, I first anticipated a tighter-pacing when I first sat down to watch it on Halloween… and I was sadly so mistaken.
In my opinion, the pacing is at its best during the first 30 minutes or so, and is used effectively to show that something is not quite right in this little slice-of-heaven Harper has retreated to. But then things actually start to fall apart around the time the police actually arrest the creepy-naked-guy stalking her rented house - you know: the point in the story where things should be getting more interesting?
I had heard about the “surreal-birthing” scene prior to watching this movie, but honestly, I was so bored by the end that I ended up skipping through this entire scene. And even if I had watched it in real time, I’m 110% confident I wouldn’t have been scared… because I was already so gosh-dang BORED!
Garland could’ve easily trimmed roughly 10, maybe even 20 minutes from the final runtime and I think that would’ve improved it significantly; it may have still been confusing, but at least it would’ve dragged along less. It’s one of the reasons I think this premise (in Garland’s hands) would’ve made a better short-film instead of a full-length feature.
Shallow Feminism
Ultimately, I think Garland’s biggest mistake with this movie is the fact that he doesn’t seem to have anything interesting, new, or even controversial, to say about the female-driven subject matter; at times it felt like he just wanted to make a “feminist film” just to say he made one. I’m not convinced he actually did the assigned reading for the project.
As I mentioned earlier, there are a number of different ideas connected to the simple premise of a widow grieving and attempting to heal from a volatile relationship: the sense of losing someone when you still remember them at their best; the sense of guilt when one person puts the entire weight of the relationship of your shoulders; the anger of realizing the lack of accountability in someone you so deeply trusted and loved.
The pain of realizing that love is gone - and that your world no longer feels safe.
There is something deeply unsettling about Harper’s situation as the events unfold: the entire town, populated by seemingly the same man, has an air of predation in almost every interaction. Even something as benign as an introductory conversation has a tinge of something eerie.
The cold-truth is, this is truly a great reflection of what every woman experiences, at least once, in the company of men. And when your personal world is marked by such a traumatic loss, it can leave women feeling even more unsafe.
That level of vulnerability is worth exploring, especially in a female-lead horror movie…
But Alex Garland misses the mark every single time! Instead of digging-deep and really exploring those horrifying aspects of grief and anxiety, he’d rather just shoot more nonsense-scenes to fill the run-time - simply because they look good.
Simply admitting that a majority of modern-men still have a touch of predation in them - to varying degrees - just isn’t enough for a folk-horror. Especially when it’s being told from the perspective of a grieving widow.
I honestly don’t know why Garland wiffed this one, guys.
I don’t know if he was too nervous about confronting some hard truths about himself, as a successful man still benefiting from a man’s world - or if he was too close to his own vision that it got in the way of bringing clarity to the message. I personally suspect it’s a little bit of both.
Now, do I think this was a lazy, preformative attempt to get his brownie-points for women’s rights? Of course not. His body of work is evidence of the contrary.
Alex Garland is talented and imaginative, and is really good at articulating the strangest ideas into engaging stories. No matter how nuanced the theme, there is typically a pointed message to be gleaned by the movie’s end.
I just don’t know what he is trying to say here with MEN. And, at various points during the movie, I started doubting if he even knew what he wanted to say with MEN.
Ultimately, you can give this folk-horror-feature a soft-pass, unless you don’t mind being bored for over an hour and half (or unless you’re looking for new ideas for your dream-cottage-Pinterest-board).
With 2 out 5 stars, I cannot in good conscience recommend this movie… though I would highly recommend it for a remake in about a decade or so.