Too Old to be THIS Stupid!

If there’s anything you should know about me it’s this: I’m a big classic literature fan. I’m the one who walked away from my high school reading of “The Scarlet Letter” and said to myself: “you know, I actually kind of enjoyed that.”

I’m the middle school-er who willing checked out the school’s copy of “Moby Dick” - then followed it up with “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde” for some light-reading.

Shoot, I’m the one who keeps recommending classic titles in my local book club…

So when I learned that there is a prequel film to Henry James’ “The Turn of the Screw,” I decided to watch it out of sheer morbid curiosity…

Unfortunately.

 

A Quick Refresher:

So, first thing’s first, we need to tackle the basics of “The Turn of the Screw,” by Henry James:

For those who haven’t seen Netflix’s The Haunting of Bly Manor (yes, that series is an adaptation), “The Turn of the Screw” has been adapted a couple of times - though most notably in the form of The Innocents from 1961…


A Gothic novella from 1898, it tells the story of a young governess who is sent to care for the recently orphaned, Miles and Flora, at Bly Manor. The children are incredibly clever and disarmingly charming (especially Miles), but it’s not long until the Governess notices the strange happenings - if not outright hauntings - of previous inhabitants of the house:

the former governess, Miss Jessel and the gardener, Peter Quint.

Fearing that these ghostly forces aim to corrupt the young children, the Governess takes it up on herself to save their souls from their influence… but, little does she realize, it may be too late.


Now, I’ll be the first to admit: like other pieces of classic Western literature, I struggled (a lot) to read my way through this one. Despite how short it is, it is a slow-read simply due to the changes in popular writing-styles. But once I got through it, I walked away really thinking… “dear God, that was a slog I wasn’t prepared for!”

But then my second prevailing-thought was: “that’s a pretty disturbing story.”

And the fact is: it’s supposed to be.

What makes “The Turn of the Screw” really stand out to me, and what makes me keep coming back to it, is the fact that it is incredibly haunting; modern audiences absolutely don’t scare as easily as back in 1898, but this is one of those stories that just sticks with you and makes you maul it over - even if you don’t want to. See - haunting.

I love this story because of how much it creeps me out, and it helped introduce me to a writer I never would’ve heard about, had it not been for the 1961 film or the source material.

 

The Prequel Curse:

Now, I plan to write an entire essay about the glory that is The Innocents, and how it is a perfect adaptation.

But that is not this essay, unfortunately.

All you need to know about that movie is that it is haunting in it’s own right as it takes the time to meditate on, then run with, it’s source material. The scenes may not be 1-to-1, but it certainly captures the spirit and ambiance of the story while incorporating its own flare.

1971’s The Nightcomers does none of the above, and it literally made me crash-out in front of my dog…


What makes James’ short story so good in the first place, is the fact that he really leans into the ambiguity of the tale: many questions are left unanswered and the fates of several characters are never revealed.

Additionally, we, the readers, genuinely don’t know if the spooky happenings are a true haunting, or simply the manifestations of a mind slowly unraveling (something the ‘61 film adapts very skillfully to play up the tension). James makes the choice to keep the true history of Bly Manor hidden from our sight which increases the potency of the horror:

Even though a debaucherous relationship is heavily implied between Miss Jessel and Quint, the reader has no way of knowing to what extent - let alone how much the children were directly impacted by the affair (again, it’s strongly hinted at, but never outright confirmed).

Everything in both the novella and the ‘61 movie feels like it has been carefully planned for a horrific pay-off in the end…. meanwhile, everything in 1971’s The Nightcomers feels lackadaisical, with shock elements thrown in for “good measure.”

 

The Nightcomers suffers from what I’ve been calling “the prequel-curse;” similar in function and design to the dreaded “sequel-curse,” this version is actually so much worse because a prequel story (in my opinion) offers more flexibility for world-building and developing relationships between established characters.

And with elements as intriguing as corruption, ambiguity, and love-and-hate, it’s a little infuriating to see this opportunity so badly wasted!

In the case of “The Turn of the Screw,” there are so many unknowns inherent to the story, that it’s basically a field-day-in-waiting for all the weird, creepy, and fun things you could run with for creating a prequel story. The only caveat to this Gothic-buffet, is that the story should remain Gothic in some small form - especially as it has the potential to really play up the tragedy for the fate of the children.

I sense that the filmmakers either weren’t sure how to approach this challenge (especially since “the Gothic” has evolved a lot since James’ time), or they just didn’t trust their own audience to be able to follow the story line.
Or both, let’s be honest - two things can be true at the same time.


Since I really don’t want to keep this movie in my brain any longer than I need to, I’m going to just tackle my biggest issue with this movie - one that serves as a through-line for every other problem it has in it’s story.

No spoilers will be available for this one… but let’s face it, I watched this movie so that you don’t have to. Seek out those spoilers at your own risk!

 

0 to 60… Makes a Bad Mystery

Ultimately, this movie has zero build-up - and, consequently, zero pay-off:

  • We’re introduced to the hedonistic nature of Jessel and Quint’s relationship almost immediately, but with no explanation as to how they got there in the first place;

  • We’re dropped right in front Quint’s cynically amoral perspective and personal philosophies, but Marlon Brando (yes, they cast the Godfather for this one… for some reason) isn’t given the chance to explore his own character;

  • We’re supposed to believe that Miles and Flora started out as perfectly well-adjusted children, and it is only through Quint’s influence their minds are twisted… but we are never given the chance to see them being anything more than creepy little hell-spawn (especially Miles);

There are bunch of different directions they could’ve taken the established Gothic-troupes, and each one would’ve made a more compelling story. But the producers, the director, the writers - whom ever it was - chose to play it safe and broke the cardinal rule of all story-telling:

They chose to Tell, not Show….

And it’s a challenge to make that strategy work, especially for a character-driven tale.

Honestly, I think it’s symptomatic of a larger problem plaguing the movie: the filmmakers clearly don’t trust that their own audience is smart enough to follow a heady, tragic romance about the nature of corruption.


Final Thoughts

When I say I crashed-out in front of my dog, I am being totally serious:

I had the living room to myself for the afternoon and decided to take a wack at my hilariously long DVR list. And since my morbid-curiosity was suddenly reignited, I decided to tackle the one movie I never would’ve watched unless I saw The Innocence first.

About 3 drinks later, I found myself screaming at the TV: “I’m sorry, but those kids are TOO old to be THIS STUPID!!”


Even though the boy cast as Miles nailed the vacant, 1,000-yard stare that actually works for the character, it doesn’t make sense that two preteens would develop these wicked-machinations on their own (unless they were born-sociopaths… which is still my second working theory). As isolated as they may be, both figuratively and literally, they’re at about that age where there should be some push-back - even against the ones they most trust and respect.

But because they were presented as being as emotional mature as a pair of actual 6-year-olds, I just couldn’t immerse myself in the narrative… especially since Marlon Brando’s Quint seemed so detached, that his own machinations (and his own “influence”) ultimately felt pointless.


And so, after my ranting and raving finally died out, I turned to my dog, Rocky, to gauge his opinions on the movie we sat through: he gazed at me with his own 1,000 yard stare, cocked his head to the side, and pranced out of the living room.

Though I still don’t know how to interpret this action, one thing I do know for sure:

I’m promptly deleting this movie from my memory as fast as humanly possible - which means it’s time for an Emily Bronte cleanser!

(jk- Heathcliff pisses me off too much, and my dog already judges me for it)