Nancy Drew… Detective (1938) was a surprisingly fun Saturday morning view.
Classic cinema is not for everyone. This is a fact I’ve always had to remember, and have only just recently chilled out about.
But when I say this first adaptation of the beloved teen-sleuth is one of the greatest things I’ve seen in a while, I am not even kidding…
This movie is AWESOME.
Based on Carolyn Keene’s 1933, “The Password to Larkspur Lane,” the story follows teenage Nancy Drew as she investigates the sudden disappearance of wealthy eccentric, Mary Eldredge, just before she can donate $250,000 to the local girl’s school.
Nancy, spunky, sharp, but slightly breezy (by today’s standards), is eager to crack the case as a number of mysterious encounters crop up one by one in her normally idyllic life. Reluctantly aided by long-suffering friend and neighbor, Ted Nickerson, Nancy races against the clock to untangle a dangerous criminal web before it is too late for everyone.
Fun fact about me: I’ve never actually read any of the Nancy Drew novels when I was growing up. Not for any particular reason, of course - they just never ended up on my radar, somehow. But knowing full well who the character is, due to the many, many adaptations that have been made since her first appearance, I was very morbidly curious when I saw this title crop up on TCM’s line-up early this June.
I honestly had no idea such an early film adaptation even existed (being released only 5 years after the book was first published), and, as something of a self-taught “film connoisseur,” I am very much aware that early-20th century mysteries usually don’t paint women in a good light.
Usually.
I went into this movie completely expecting the old tried-and-true characterization I’ve already seen in so many movies of the era: a leading-lady who is either very vapid; very ditzy; very demure; or very femme-fatale. The leading-lady who, even though she’s billed as the actual hero, doesn’t usually get to do anything actually heroic.
Usually.
So color me surprised when throughout this short little romp, Nancy Drew was very much the freaking hero of her own story!
Grant it, some “feminine” stereotypes were adhered to - for example: being so frightened of a gun that she literally closes her eyes while shooting wildly (my inner hillbilly was very displeased with the lack of trigger-discipline). Though the majority of these outdated-traits are typically played up for comedic effect- usually at Ted’s expense.
But what really stood out to me during this movie is that it is Nancy who initiates the most of the action, conflict, and resolutions. And in the event when she can’t directly solve the problem herself, it is our dear Ted who then takes charge but without ever diminishing her contributions; the moments when they must work together, it really does feel like an equal team-effort… with the classic bickering that comes from childhood friendships.
Clearly the writers and director understood what they were making as much as they understood who they needed to make it for; at a brief 66 minutes, time is never wasted despite the moments of exposition and the character interactions are consistent and clear, paving the way for some truly funny moments of physical comedy.
Frankie Thomas especially stands out from the moment Ted Nickerson is introduced to the final fade-to-black. His comedic prowess is on full display through the witty banter with his co-star, Bonita Granville, and sharp timing and decision-making in the scant moments of slap-stick-shenanigans.
Classic cinema is not for everyone - this is true now and will be true another 100 years from now.
But I cannot recommend Nancy Drew… Detective enough for anyone who’s looking to dip their toes into the early 20th century of American film-making. Despite the blatantly outdated sensibilities, the simple joy of watching a teenage girl play cat-and-mouse with a crime syndicate is still alive, well, and surprisingly funny in this little 1938 gem.
Classic movie lovers are sure to get a kick out every aspect of the story: from the vintage time and place, to trying to figure out what the hell “20-38” even means (seriously, they say it at least 3 times in the movie, and my etymology-loving brain is now thoroughly tantalized).
Whether you’re looking for something new and off-the-cuff, or just to kill a little extra time, cinema-philes and casual-viewers are sure to enjoy the ride that Nancy Drew… Detective has to offer.