The Lace Reader, by Brunonia Berry, was published in 2006 and definitely embraces the vibes of that early 2000’s era that many a young Millennial still remembers fondly. A modern-day Gothic tale, it tells the story of Towner, a young Bostonian woman who returns to her home town in the wake her beloved Aunt Eva’s sudden disappearance, where she must finally confront her past - and all it’s horror - to unravel the mystery of her Aunt Eva’s fate.
There’s a good chance that you probably haven’t heard of this novel yet, despite the fact that it was so well received upon it’s initial publication - and that doesn’t really surprise me because “Booktok” was not yet a thing back in the halcyon years of 2006. But had it been around back then, I am a 110% certain it would’ve absolutely been trending - and for a long time!
The Female Perspective
This book is incredibly feminist - especially for our current times (when we’ve seen both the rise and current-fall of the “tradwife” trend online) - and tackles elements of familial trauma and misogyny in a way that is far less familiar than they used to be.
The lead character “Towner” (aka Sophya) preemptively warns the reader that she can not be trusted; “never believe me - I lie all the time.” And, within the first couple of chapters it becomes clear that her setup as the unreliable narrator is well-warranted… though may not be her own fault.
As a character: Towner is fine. While she wasn’t really my favorite character to read in a while, she certainly wasn’t the worst. In fact, once it became clear to me that she was clearly the partial product of some past trauma, it became easier to sympathize with her - even if her POV was sometimes a slog to get through.
(Berry falls into a very familiar trap for writers of her time, where in trying to be technically “good” at story craft, they end up sacrificing a part of their character’s personality in order to wax poetic about their settings and paint an “immersive picture;” pretty much the same issue you see in a story that is being framed as a bunch of diary-entries)
Not only is the book lead by an interesting female character, it is very much the story of a matriarchal family of equally interesting women - each with their own personalities and histories that make unique and relatable. And, possibly, each with their own touch of magical divinity…
Witchy Women
Before you get too excited by this, I’m afraid I’ll have to burst a small bubble: no, these female characters are not witches (per say).
Witchcraft, especially in the context of Massachusetts’ Witch Trials, defiantly play a role throughout the story. And, yes, the women in Towner’s family seem to have an inherent gift of prophecy and “reading” (literally reading minds). But whether this is a truly magical gift, manifested through their reading of Ipswitch lace, or simply a figment of Towner’s imagination, remains unanswered by the novels. But please barely in mind, I think this is a feature and not a bug in Barry’s novel, as the big twist at the end truly does re-contextualize everything you witness through Towner’s perspective.
Even if veracity of magic in the novel is left up to debate, it doesn’t change the fact that all the female characters we meet are engaging and fully-realized, and that experience was so refreshing to have after a latest string of reading not-so-interesting female leads.
There is absolutely a sense of dry, sardonic humor and wit that every woman embodies, and that alone warms my little smart-ass heart so much.
More Show, less Tell, Brunonia…
The only real gripe I had with this book is in Brunonia Barry’s writing style, and how I think it could’ve been polished up just a little bit more.
I actually had a hard time getting started with this one - and actually had to go back to restart it when I put it down for too long and actually forgot what happened in the first 80 pages.
(And I was that one freak in English Lit who never needed a bookmark for the assigned reading- not even for Hawthorne’s “The Scarlet Letter”)
I do think, for me, it was this combination of Barry writing through the eyes of a classic unreliable narrator, and her style of flowery, border-line purple-prose. On one hand, it means she did a really great job in setting up Towner with a dubious perception of the world - one that makes even more sense once you reach the book’s conclusion.
That was a choice I genuinely enjoyed because it made sudden perspective-shifts all the more telling regarding Towner’s mental state, without undermining her likability or capability as the lead character.
But on the other hand, there were also these long-breaks in the narrative where an entire sub-backstory needed to be explained - even if the vignette itself never actually came back up again. In my opinion, most of these memories we experience through Towner’s eyes could’ve been tapered down a little bit more, or presented in a different way that didn’t keep pausing the flow of the story; honestly, that’s why I had to take a break from the book in the first place - it just got really jarring that the story would keep pausing for a smaller story that never came up again.
Interestingly enough, though, I feel that Barry really shines when it comes to writing dialogue. In the chapters that shift to another character’s POV, there was always such snappy back and forth between the characters that it elicited delighted chortles and surprised gasps on my part. But it’s having to get through Towner’s more meandering inner-thoughts, first, that can make the first act of the book feel like a chore.
Ultimately, The Lace Reader is an intriguing and even haunting story about reconciliation; finding the courage to face one’s past demons, rather run from them, so that you can fully step into your own power…
a very heavy feat I think many women can relate to at least once.
While I wouldn’t necessarily describe it as “hypnotic,” I would say it is captivating once you get through that first 100 pages or so. The twist at the end, while admittedly predictable at first glance, is revealed in such a way that makes it feel chillingly inevitable, if not almost natural to Towner’s story.
It’s defiantly kept this book in my brain-space long after the final page.
Awarding it a 3.5 out of 5 stars, and a solid 7 out of 10 on overall satisfaction, I do recommend this book for a once over if you’re looking for something a little more esoteric to pick up this Halloween season.